So there was a bat blog around originated by Matt who runs the Diamond Jesters blog where you could flex and show off/share the best hits you ever pulled.
I left a comment in the original post laying out the best "hits" from an objective standpoint but they would be as follows.
2011 Bowman Chrome Ryan Pressly Superfractor 1/1 (Note: I found the blogpost by Match-Up where they scanned and shared this super)
2011 Topps Marquee Troy Tulowitzki Red 1/1
2012 Topps Chrome Will Middlebrooks Printing Plate 1/1
2012 Bowman Draft Christian Yelich Futures Game Jumbo Relic /25
2012 Bowman Sterling Yu Darvish Japanese Player Rookie Card Autograph /75
Honorable mentions:
2013 Bowman Draft Aaron Blanton Printing Plate 1/1
2013 Panini Prizm Draft Kris Bryant Gold Autograph /10
2016 BBM Homecoming Hiroki Kuroda patch /30
2011 Topps Update Mike Trout Rookie Card
2011 Bowman Draft Picks and Prospects Mike Trout Rookie Card (Chrome)
2011 Bowman Draft Picks and Prospects Mike Trout Rookie Card (Paper) x3
Objectively these would be the "best" cards I ever pulled. In terms of rarity and their value on the second hand market.
But subjectively, out of the 11 cards I listed I only have one still in my possession.
As cool as a lot of the stuff I've pulled over the years has been, the fact remains that I never really valued them because they were always just tradebait to get me what I really wanted. In the case of the Trouts, I pulled them in 2011 when he started his MLB career looking like a scrub so those cards weren't really much of anything to me. Even after 2012 I still only saw them as improved tradebait and not anything to actually bother keeping.
So I thought I'd take a different approach and give this topic a little bit more time to marinate and come together. I'll go an alternative route and present what would be the top 5 best cards I ever pulled in the context of how I was thrilled to pull them, and against all odds I still have them now.
You all know how often I turn over my inventory and pull the plug on my collections, do you know how hard it is for a card to stay with me? Well maybe these will hold the answer to how that's possible.
#1 2016 BBM Homecoming Hiroki Kuroda patch /30
This is the only card in the list above (an honorable mention at that) that's still with me. For obvious reasons.
#2 2012 Topps Allen & Ginter Ichiro Suzuki jersey relic
I opened four (4!) hobby boxes of A&G in 2012 and the 11 other hits were all garbage. By a wide margin, the best thing I pulled in the four (4!) hobby boxes was that Ichiro jersey relic. It's not even serially numbered but who cares, pulling a "hit" of Ichiro is always cool. Or at least I convinced myself it was to cope.
#3 2010 Tristar Pursuit Gary Sanchez Autograph /80
In a way this card is ass because if you look closely, you can see that the geniuses at Tristar bungled cutting the autograph sticker. There's fragments of two different signatures on the top and bottom. I'm pretty sure this lack of quality control is why they've since been banished to regional autograph shows and signed memorabilia.
But anyway when I pulled this in 2012, El Gary was one of the New York Yankees' best prospects and I was absolutely thrilled to nab an autograph of his. The shitty sticker sucks, there's still something charming about a serially numbered autograph card of a player you absolutely wanted to have and pulled when you least expected it. It's to the point where I was okay with moving on from my 2010 Bowman Chrome autograph because I had this card. Do you know how strong an attachment has to be to oppose the Chrome is King principle and willingly keep the unlicensed card with badly cut autograph sticker?
She's hot.
#5 TBD
There is no fifth "hit" I've actually kept that I think is worth mentioning. There is a card or two that could round out this spot but I'd rather have something worthy of being catapulted to this list than just having an obvious placeholder that only exists to get jettisoned.
There's also a part of me that wants to leave the fifth spot open just because I am okay with being hopeful it comes along.
I don't open boxes or packs nearly as much as I used to. But I do think I'll probably buy something again when I deem that there's a card in the checklist I really really want. Having a whole case break is something of a bucket list item of mine. Just waiting for a product where I can just be like "yup, that's the one" and go in on.
So big thanks to Matt for the fun little blogging exercise.
And thank you (the readers) for stopping by.
Take care.